Jake McCoy, a right‑handed pitcher who moved from the University of South Carolina to the University of Tennessee this offseason, heard his name called in the 18th round of the 2026 MLB Draft by the Toronto Blue Jays, the 552nd overall selection.
Ranked as the 152nd prospect by MLB Pipeline and 156th by ESPN, McCoy had been projected to hear his name in the first two rounds, but a torn ulnar collateral ligament forced him to undergo Tommy John surgery and miss the entire 2026 campaign.
During his sophomore season in 2025 he made 14 starts, posting a 4‑5 record, a 6.90 ERA and a 1.70 WHIP over 60 innings, striking out 77 batters while walking 40 and being hit by pitch 17 times.
Recovery and Outlook
The surgery has placed his recovery timeline into the next calendar year, but the Blue Jays remain optimistic that the arm will regain its pre‑injury velocity. If he returns to full health, analysts believe he could re‑enter the draft conversation for the 2027 class, potentially as a mid‑round pick with upside.
McCoy's commitment decision in June 2025 highlighted his preference for Tennessee, where he chose the Volunteers over LSU and South Carolina, a choice that underscored his desire to develop within the SEC environment.
The broader baseball community watches his progress, as the pitcher aims to translate his collegiate experience into professional success.