The latest episode of The Common Fan Podcast brings together two of Nebraska’s most respected football voices: Gary Sharp of the Omaha World‑Herald and Brandon Vogel, who writes the Counter Read newsletter. Together they tackle a question that has lingered among Husker fans for years — who truly belongs on the state’s all‑time offensive Mount Rushmore, if quarterbacks are left off the list.
The Podcast’s Framework
Their discussion starts with a look at the players who shaped Nebraska’s rushing attacks. Sharp points out that Lawrence Phillips is widely regarded as the most naturally gifted running back to ever wear a Cornhusker jersey, while the conversation also touches on the off‑field controversies that have colored the legacies of several stars.
Beyond the headline names, the duo expands the conversation to a broader pool that includes Roger Craig, Calvin Jones, Roy Helu, Rex Burkhead and Ameer Abdullah. Each brings a different chapter to the story of Nebraska’s offense, from versatile playmakers to workhorse backs who carried the team through pivotal seasons.
Sharp argues that the offensive line, often overlooked in such debates, deserves its own spotlight. He highlights legends such as Dave Rimington, Dean Steinkuhler, Aaron Taylor, Bob Brown, Will Shields, Zach Wiegert and Aaron Graham as the backbone that made the rushing attacks possible.
A Rushmore of Legends
The podcast’s evaluation framework centers on a simple question: would the player’s presence be essential to telling the story of Nebraska football? Using that lens, the hosts narrow the field to a four‑player summit that includes Mike Rozier, Dave Rimington, Johnny Rodgers and Ahman Green.
Johnny Rodgers stands out as the only athlete to have earned a spot on two different Mount Rushmores this summer, underscoring his lasting impact on the program’s identity. The final list, while sure to spark further debate, offers a snapshot of the talent and character that have defined Nebraska’s offensive heritage.