Fantasy football drafts have long treated the third‑wide‑receiver slot as a safe harbor for late‑round flips, but the 2025 season is reshaping that narrative. This year, three players who are currently being drafted as WR3s — DK Metcalf, Alec Pierce, and DJ Moore — are generating buzz because each carries the upside of a potential WR1.
The Metcalf Factor in Pittsburgh
DK Metcalf enters his second season with the Steelers after a trade that brought Michael Pittman Jr. and rookie Germie Bernard into the mix. Though the competition is stiffer, Metcalf’s size and deep‑ball skill set remain rare, and new head coach Mike McCarthy is expected to unleash a more aggressive passing attack. Last season he averaged 15.7 PPR points per game over the first six weeks, a pace that placed him at WR23 for the year.
The Steelers’ offensive philosophy under McCarthy emphasizes vertical stretches, which could free Metcalf to exploit his 6‑3, 215‑pound frame. Even with increased competition, his target share when Pittman was off the field last year suggests he can still be a reliable weekly starter.
Pierce’s New Deal in Indianapolis
Alec Pierce signed a four‑year, $114 million contract this offseason, cementing his status as the Colts’ No. 1 receiver. His target share jumped to 26.9% when Michael Pittman was not on the field last season, indicating a clear pathway to a higher volume of throws. With Pittman’s departure, Pierce is poised to see a surge in targets, making him a compelling WR3 who could break into WR1 territory.
Moore’s Buffalo Reboot
DJ Moore is joining the Buffalo Bills, a team that finished second in rushing play rate last season but lacked a consistent go‑to receiver. After a down 2025 campaign, Moore posted 98 catches for the Bears in 2024, showcasing his big‑play ability. Under head coach Joe Brady, the Bills may balance their run‑heavy scheme with more aerial threats, giving Moore a chance to rebound as a WR1.
The fantasy implications are clear. Metcalf, Pierce, and Moore each carry a blend of proven production and untapped upside. If their respective offenses click, they could outperform their current WR3 ADP and become weekly starter options, reshaping the value of late‑round picks.