The Numbers Behind the Rankings
Pro Football Focus has placed Deshaun Watson at the bottom of its 32‑player starting quarterback list, a reflection of both his limited snaps and a modest 60.7 passing grade compiled from 2022 through 2024. Watson’s 6.0 yards per attempt underscores a struggle to move the ball, while his 33.1 Total QBR since joining the Browns ranks as the lowest among qualified passers.
Shedeur Sanders, despite a stellar college résumé, entered the league with a 42.3 PFF grade, positioning him second‑worst among 43 qualifying rookies. He completed 69.8% of his passes in 2025, a figure that placed him sixth from the bottom, and he finished the season with 1,400 yards, seven touchdowns and ten interceptions.
Injury History and Its Impact
Watson’s 2025 campaign was canceled after he suffered two torn Achilles tendons, an injury that has kept him sidelined and limited his on‑field evaluation. The Browns have watched him accumulate just 3,365 passing yards and 19 touchdowns while throwing 12 interceptions in limited action.
The team’s coaching staff has indicated that a competition will unfold during training camp and the preseason, but the narrative has shifted toward giving Sanders the first opportunity, especially as fans voice growing impatience with Watson’s inconsistent performance.
Fan Sentiment and the Push for Sanders
Cleveland’s fan base has rallied around Sanders, citing his college accolades and the belief that his skill set could revitalize an offense that has been hampered by Watson’s underwhelming production. Social media chatter and local radio debates frequently reference Sanders as the quarterback who could restore optimism.
Analysts have begun to speculate that the Browns might deliberately underperform in the upcoming season, a strategy that could improve their chances of securing a top draft pick in 2027. Such a plan would align with a broader rebuild narrative that prioritizes long‑term assets over short‑term wins.