Preseason polls in Division II football serve as an early barometer, reflecting how coaches and media perceive each program’s potential heading into a new campaign. The latest releases from the CIAA, SIAC and MIAA conferences have already sparked conversation about which squads might defy expectations and which traditional powers could be dethroned.
In the SIAC, the poll placed Edward Waters at the summit despite a modest 5‑5 record a year ago, a surprise that underscores the conference’s unpredictable nature. The ranking also highlighted the influx of talent at several historically black institutions, setting the stage for fresh storylines.
SIAC Surprise: Edward Waters atop the rankings
Coaches praised the Warriors’ aggressive non‑conference schedule, noting that the experience gained from close contests should translate into a stronger second half. Analysts point to the emergence of quarterback Quinn Gray as a factor that could push the team beyond preseason hype.
Meanwhile, the CIAA’s revised tournament structure, which now includes a third‑place game, aims to give more teams a realistic pathway to at‑large playoff selections. The poll reflects this shift, projecting Virginia Union as the likely No. 1 seed ahead of defending champion Johnson C. Smith.
CIAA’s New Game Format and Virginia Union’s Rise
Virginia Union’s ascent is notable not only for its on‑field performance but also for the continuity at the helm of head coach Isaiah Knowles, whose strategic adjustments have kept the team competitive despite roster turnover.
The conference’s emphasis on additional playoff opportunities has been welcomed by schools such as Albany State, Benedict and Kentucky State, all of which navigated significant player turnover last season. Their ability to adapt will be tested as the schedule unfolds.
MIAA’s Split Decision and a Champion’s Resurgence
In the MIAA, the preseason vote resulted in a split between Pittsburg State and Northwest Missouri State for the top spot, a rare occurrence that highlights the competitive balance in that league.
Pittsburg State, after a slow start in 2025, rallied to win ten consecutive games, a turnaround that many attribute to the leadership of running back Tiant Wyche and a fortified defensive line.
Northwest Missouri State, the reigning national champion, continues to hold the record for the most D2 titles with six championships, a testament to the program’s sustained excellence.
The overlapping narratives of these conferences illustrate how preseason expectations can shape recruiting, scheduling and ultimately the playoff picture, making early polls a crucial component of the Division II landscape.