Fantasy football managers who chase IDP (Individual Defensive Player) talent often look for hidden gems that can outperform their average draft position. In 2026, the landscape is shaped by three scoring models — tackle‑heavy, big‑play‑heavy, and balanced — each rewarding different skill sets. Understanding which players fit those models is the key to unlocking value before the rest of the league catches on.
Azeez Al‑Shaair, the Houston Texans linebacker, is a prime example of a tackle‑heavy workhorse. In 2024 he logged 103 total tackles, 55 assists, two interceptions, a forced fumble and a recovery while never missing a snap. His ability to handle Mike linebacker duties and stay on the field despite a zero‑sack season shows a durability that translates into consistent fantasy points, especially in formats that prize volume.
Alex Anzalone’s move to Tampa Bay adds a new layer of intrigue. The former New Orleans defender posted 95 tackles, 52 solo stops, 43 assists, four tackles for loss, 2.5 sacks and an interception last year. Now he steps into the role vacated by Lavonte David, inheriting a more central spot in a defense that is being reshaped under new coordinator Todd Bowles. That increased responsibility could boost his sack and turnover numbers.
Caleb Downs, the Dallas Cowboys’ rookie safety, brings a rare blend of versatility. Drafted for his ability to excel in run defense, pass coverage and pressure packages, Downs can rotate single‑high, play nickel or blitz on command. That flexibility makes him a strong candidate in balanced and tackle‑heavy leagues, where his all‑purpose skill set can be leveraged across multiple defensive packages.
Jaelan Phillips’ 2024 campaign was limited to eight games, yet he still managed two sacks, 28 combined tackles and a forced fumble. With Nic Scourton sidelined by injury and the team’s scheme expected to generate more designed rush opportunities, Phillips is poised to see a higher snap count and more pass‑rushing chances in 2025. That upside makes him a compelling late‑round flier.
Scoring format ultimately dictates where fantasy managers should prioritize these sleepers. In tackle‑heavy leagues, Al‑Shaair and Downs become anchor pieces, while big‑play‑heavy formats may favor Anzalone’s sack potential and Phillips’ pass‑rush upside. Balanced leagues reward a mix of all three, encouraging managers to diversify their IDP portfolio.
Draft Strategy Takeaway
The takeaway for 2026 drafts is simple: target players whose role is expanding, whose snap counts are set to rise, and whose statistical categories align with the league’s scoring emphasis. By focusing on Al‑Shaair, Anzalone, Downs and Phillips, managers can secure IDP assets that are undervalued today but likely to pay dividends when the season unfolds.