The rivalry between Central Michigan University and Michigan State has long been framed by the latter's storied tradition, yet the Chippewas have carved out a remarkable niche by securing three improbable victories over the Spartans. These triumphs, achieved in 1991, 1992 and 2009, are more than statistical footnotes; they represent moments when strategy, grit and individual brilliance converged to overturn expectations.
The first breakthrough came in 1991 when Central Michigan, led by coach Herb Deromedi, traveled to East Lansing and stunned No. 18‑ranked Michigan State 20‑3. Billy Smith powered the offense with 162 rushing yards and a touchdown, while Doug Adler’s decisive defensive stop on Tico Duckett set the tone early. The Chippewas outgained the Spartans 346‑281 in total yards, a testament to a balanced attack that included a 57‑yard strike from Jeff Bender to Ken Ealy that opened the second half.
A year later, the two teams met again and Central Michigan repeated the upset, this time edging Michigan State 24‑20. Joe Youngblood, who earned MAC Player of the Week honors, threw for 163 yards and orchestrated a 69‑yard drive in the fourth quarter that sealed the win. Safety Darrall Stinson forced a crucial fumble, and Leo Griffin contributed 90 of the team’s 141 rushing yards, underscoring a collective effort that left the Spartans reeling.
The 2009 Turning Point
The most widely watched clash arrived in 2009, when Central Michigan faced Michigan State before a national audience on ESPN2. A last‑second 42‑yard field goal by Andrew Aguila delivered a 29‑27 victory that cemented the Chippewas’ place in the rivalry’s lore. Dan LeFevour, who completed 33 passes for 328 yards and three touchdowns, connected with Paris Cotton for a touchdown that pulled the team within a point, setting up Bryan Anderson’s onside kick recovery that positioned Aguila for the game‑winner. The defense also shone, outgaining the Spartans 418‑316 in total yards.
Coaching continuity played a subtle yet pivotal role in these achievements. Herb Deromedi’s early successes paved the way for Butch Jones, who became the second Central Michigan coach in seven meetings to defeat Michigan State. Both mentors leveraged distinct offensive philosophies while emphasizing a disciplined defense that consistently limited the Spartans’ explosiveness.
Beyond the scoreboard, these victories resonated with the university community and the broader Mid‑American Conference, inspiring future generations of players and fans. The 1991, 1992 and 2009 wins are frequently cited in discussions of underdog narratives, illustrating how meticulous preparation and execution can defy conventional hierarchies in college football.