Former SMU women’s basketball standout Kyla Deck has filed a federal lawsuit against the NCAA and her alma mater, Southern Methodist University, alleging that recent transfer portal restrictions infringe on federal antitrust law.
Legal Challenge Unfolds in Dallas
Deck argues that the NCAA’s ‘ghost transfer’ rule, which bars athletes who did not enter the portal during the 2025‑26 window from using fifth‑year eligibility earned through the Wisne v. NCAA decision, would strip her of a scholarship, playing eligibility and the NIL earnings she has already secured.
The complaint, filed in the Northern District of Texas in Dallas, seeks a preliminary injunction that would block the enforcement of those restrictions, allowing Deck to continue her collegiate career without the threat of losing scholarships or compensation.
Legal experts note that the case could set a broader precedent, as dozens of Division I athletes who obtained an extra year of eligibility without entering the portal now face similar hurdles. A ruling in Deck’s favor might force the NCAA to reconsider how it applies transfer waivers.
SMU has indicated that no roster spot remains for Deck, heightening the urgency of her legal bid. The NCAA and SMU have not yet responded to requests for comment.