Maddy Shirley’s Jersey Retired: A Milestone for Central High School Basketball
Maddy Shirley, a standout guard for Central High School, will see her No. 32 jersey retired, making her the first basketball player in the school’s history to receive that honor. The ceremony will be held during a girls basketball game next season, marking a rare tribute in Evansville high school sports.
Over her four‑year career she amassed 2,113 points, tying her for 38th in state history, and collected 1,069 rebounds, a feat achieved by only a dozen other female athletes in Indiana. She also holds the program records for points, rebounds and blocks, underscoring her all‑around dominance on the court.
Accolades and Impact
Shirley’s list of honors reads like a who’s who of high school basketball. She earned Junior All‑Star status, was selected twice to the Supreme 15 All‑State team and captured three consecutive Courier & Press Metro Player of the Year awards. The team captured three sectional championships and claimed its first regional title in 2025 with her leading the charge. In a memorable semi‑state performance she scored 46 points against top‑ranked Greensburg, a total that places her tied for eighth in Indiana High School Athletic Association postseason history.
The retirement ceremony itself was a surprise for Shirley. Principal Andrew Freeman presented the news, and a dedicated display case will soon house her jersey inside the gymnasium. In remarks, she thanked her coaches, teammates and the broader community for their unwavering support, noting that the honor ranks among the pinnacles of her Central High career.
The gesture follows a local tradition of honoring exceptional athletes. Bosse High School retired Mekhi Lairy’s No. 2 in 2019, setting a precedent that Central’s decision continues. Such retirements are uncommon in Evansville basketball, making Shirley’s recognition a landmark event for the region.
Beyond the personal accolades, Shirley’s legacy will inspire future generations of players at Central High and throughout the city. Her story illustrates how sustained excellence, combined with community backing, can leave an indelible mark on school history.