The makings of a surprise contender
The Heisman Trophy has become a stage where preseason obscurity often gives way to sudden stardom. In the past decade, five of the ten winners entered the season with odds of 35‑to‑1 or longer, underscoring how unpredictable the award can be.
This year’s conversation is already being reshaped by a handful of quarterbacks who, while not the headline act, possess the talent and situation to flip the script. Their stories are built on a mix of elite arm strength, dynamic playmaking ability, and the chance to lead teams that could break into the national title conversation.
At Alabama, Keelon Russell arrives as the most decorated quarterback prospect since Bryce Young. If he wins the starting role and the Crimson Tide positions itself as a title contender, Russell could quickly become the face of a new Heisman narrative.
Miami’s Malachi Toney burst onto the scene as one of college football’s most electric playmakers last season. Should the Hurricanes meet the expectations set for them this fall, Toney’s knack for turning broken plays into big gains could thrust him into Heisman discussions.
South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers brings a rare blend of size, speed, and arm strength. If the Gamecocks’ offense clicks and the team emerges as a contender, Sellers could leverage his physical tools to earn Heisman buzz.
Auburn’s Byrum Brown is another arm talent who could crash the conversation if first‑year coach Alex Golesh can steer the Tigers into immediate contention. The combination of Brown’s skill set and Golesh’s offensive vision creates a compelling scenario for a breakout.
BYU’s Bear Bachmeier, who showed flashes of dynamic play last year, could also factor into the race if the Cougars build on their recent momentum. A strong start under Bachmeier’s leadership might put him on the radar of Heisman voters.
Finally, SMU’s Kevin Jennings has already guided the Mustangs to sustained success. Should the team contend for another ACC title and a College Football Playoff berth, Jennings could force his way into the Heisman dialogue.
Why the unexpected rise matters
The possibility of long‑shot contenders reflects a broader shift in college football, where depth of talent and innovative offensive schemes are eroding the traditional power hierarchy. If any of these underrated quarterbacks ascend, the Heisman race could once again prove how unpredictable the sport can be.