The latest rankings published by The Hockey Writers have stirred conversation across the NHL community, positioning Mark Stone at the summit of the 34‑year‑old cohort while leaving Artemi Panarin with only an honorable mention.
Stone's Strengths and Limitations
Stone, celebrated for his defensive acumen and leadership, helped the Vegas Golden Knights reach the Stanley Cup Finals last spring, yet his on‑ice presence has been limited to a single 70‑game season since 2018, raising questions about his durability over a full campaign.
In contrast, Panarin has compiled nine consecutive seasons with a point per game or better, showcasing a blend of offensive creativity, physical resilience, and playmaking that has kept him among the league’s most reliable producers.
The Value of Consistency
What sets Panarin apart is not a single standout season but a sustained pattern of excellence that stretches across nearly a decade, a factor that many analysts argue should weigh heavily in any player‑of‑the‑year discussion.
As the 900‑game milestone approaches, the Russian winger is on track to join the exclusive 1,000‑point club before his next birthday, a milestone that could further cement his legacy and shift the narrative around his overall value.