The Big 12 enters the 2025 season with perhaps the deepest pool of quarterbacks in recent memory, a mix of seasoned veterans and high‑upside newcomers that has analysts scrambling to rank them from worst to best.
The Heisman Race Heats Up
At the top of the conversation sits Drew Mestemaker of Oklahoma State, who after transferring to the Cowboys has quickly become the conference’s leading Heisman contender, flashing the arm talent and poise that made him a star at his previous stop.
Not far behind, Arizona’s Noah Fifita brings a wealth of experience to the field, his 2025 statistics already hinting at a potential Heisman‑caliber 2026 campaign if he can stay healthy and continue to elevate his play.
Baylor’s DJ Lagway possesses elite physical tools — size, arm strength, and athleticism — but his decision‑making still requires refinement, a factor that could determine whether he lives up to the lofty expectations placed upon him.
Arizona State’s Cutter Boley offers a high ceiling thanks to a cannon arm and playmaking ability, yet his floor is tempered by a tendency to turn the ball over, making consistency the key to unlocking his potential.
Texas Tech’s Will Hammond is working his way back from a major knee injury; his recovery will be closely watched, as his performance could swing the Red Raiders’ fortunes in a tightly contested conference race.
Kansas State’s Avery Johnson is widely regarded as immensely talented, but the young quarterback has yet to string together the full package of accuracy, leadership, and poise that could make him a true difference‑maker.
TCU’s Jaden Craig brings size and a strong arm to the Horned Frogs, qualities that have scouts praising his ceiling while noting that his development will hinge on reducing turnovers.
BYU’s Bear Bachmeier is known for his reliability and toughness; a steady decision‑maker who can manage the game effectively, though his upside may be limited compared to more explosive peers.
Houston’s Conner Weigman, despite a history of injuries, is viewed as a complete package at quarterback, blending arm strength, mobility, and a deep understanding of offensive schemes.
Utah’s Devon Dampier stands out as a dynamic all‑around player, combining a powerful arm with elite running ability that makes him a dual‑threat menace for defenses.
The conference also features other notable arms such as Julian Lewis, Michael Hawkins Jr., Jaylen Raynor, JC French IV, Cole Ballard, Scotty Fox Jr., Brendan Sorsby, Isaiah Marshall, Chase Jenkins, Collin Klein, and many more, each adding a unique flavor to the competitive landscape.
Overall, the depth and variety of talent across the Big 12 suggest that the quarterback position will be a decisive factor in determining which teams rise to the top, making this season one of the most exciting quarterback battles in recent conference history.