As fantasy football managers gear up for the 2026 season, the question of which quarterbacks can be counted on for a steady stream of points has never been more pertinent.
The Consistency Engine: Allen and Hurts
Among the candidates, Buffalo’s Josh Allen stands out as the most dependable option, having posted QB1 finishes in 2023 and a near‑identical QB2 showing in 2024, with 410.9 and 385.1 points respectively. His ability to turn designed runs inside the ten‑yard line into touchdowns adds a reliable floor that many peers lack.
Philadelphia’s Jalen Hurts, often overlooked in the conversation, has delivered three consecutive seasons of QB2 or better production, finishing as QB9 in 2025 with 305.0 points and QB8 in 2024 with 320.0 points. Mobility remains a cornerstone of his game, allowing him to maintain a scoring floor even when his top receiver departs.
Mahomes and Stafford: Comebacks and Consistency
Kansas City’s Patrick Mahomes, returning from a torn ACL, is already ahead of schedule, finishing as QB11 in 2025 with 296.7 points, showing that his elite arm talent can still produce despite a reshaped supporting cast. Los Angeles’ Matthew Stafford, drafted as a QB2, exceeded expectations by finishing as QB3 with 358.3 points, thanks to a potent weapons array and Sean McVay’s scheme.
Strategic Takeaways
For those building lineups, targeting Allen and Hurts early can secure a high floor, whereas Mahomes and Stafford offer upside at a slightly later draft slot, especially in leagues that reward upside over consistency. The common thread among these four is their capacity to deliver a predictable weekly output, a trait that fantasy managers prize above flash‑in‑the‑pan performances.
Ultimately, the data points to a quartet of quarterbacks whose blend of talent, scheme and health trajectories make them the safest bets for the upcoming fantasy season.