As fantasy football drafts heat up, analysts are scrutinizing every potential sleeper, and one name that has sparked debate is Carolina Panthers running back Jonathon Brooks.
The Injury Factor
Eric Karabell, a veteran ESPN fantasy analyst, recently cautioned against selecting Brooks early, citing a combination of injury history and an uncertain role in the Panthers' offense.
Brooks entered the league as a second‑round pick in 2024, generating buzz after a strong offseason workout program, but his career has been marred by knee problems, including multiple ACL tears that have limited him to just three appearances since 2024.
A Crowded Backfield
The Panthers' rushing attack struggled in 2025, ranking 19th in yards per game, which further clouds the outlook for any back hoping to become a primary ball‑carrier.
Compounding the uncertainty is the presence of Chuba Hubbard, who is projected as a more reliable RB3 option and is expected to absorb the bulk of carries if Brooks cannot stay healthy.
Karabell's recommendation is to treat Brooks as a high‑risk, high‑reward prospect, perhaps drafting him late or watching his waiver wire availability before committing a roster spot.