Preseason Watch List Overview
The 2026 Buck Buchanan Award, presented by Stats Perform, continues its tradition of spotlighting the most dominant defensive forces in the Football Championship Subdivision. This season, four standout defenders from the Colonial Athletic Association have earned preseason placement on the watch list, each bringing a blend of experience and emerging talent to the conversation.
Brodie Carroll of Elon, who earned All‑CAA second‑team honors last season, logged 104 tackles, 9.5 tackles for loss, 3.5 sacks and two forced fumbles, establishing himself as a reliable anchor on the defensive line. Rohan Davy from Rhode Island contributed 101 tackles, 13.0 tackles for loss, seven sacks and five quarterback hurries, numbers that helped him secure a strong preseason profile. Anthony Ferrelli of Stony Brook, also a second‑team All‑CAA selection, recorded 109 tackles, 6.5 tackles for loss, an interception and a forced fumble, showcasing versatility across the secondary. Jaeden Jones at Monmouth posted 118 stops, five tackles for loss, an interception and a forced fumble, earning AFCA second‑team All‑America accolades and reinforcing his reputation as a playmaker.
Award History and Selection Process
The Buck Buchanan Award, first given in 1995, has become a benchmark for defensive excellence in the FCS. Presented annually by Stats Perform, the honor recognizes the national defensive player of the year and marks its 32nd season this year. Selection to the preseason watch list reflects both established leaders and rising stars who have demonstrated impact through tackles, sacks, forced fumbles and other game‑changing statistics.
Fans and analysts alike will watch closely as these players develop over the upcoming season, with the award’s final recipient to be announced after the championship concludes. The recognition not only celebrates individual achievement but also highlights the growing competitiveness of defensive play within the CAA and the broader FCS landscape.