The preseason rankings released by analyst JD Pickell placed Notre Dame’s quarterback‑wide receiver combination at No. 5, a spot that has drawn sharp criticism from fans and commentators alike. The list identifies the duo as CJ Carr and Mylan Graham, but the author contends that the evaluation lacks depth and overlooks key contributors.
Why the Rankings Miss the Mark
Jordan Faison, a national champion lacrosse player who walked on to the university, has demonstrated versatility and work ethic that extend beyond his primary sport, earning respect from teammates and coaches. His performance on the field, marked by precise route running and reliable hands, suggests a readiness for a larger role in the offense.
Mylan Graham, while highly touted in recruiting circles, has yet to translate those expectations into measurable on‑field impact, a fact that the author believes should temper his placement above more proven performers.
The author argues that recruiting rankings often color public perception, leading to an undervaluation of players who excel through performance rather than pedigree.
Implications for the Squad
If the coaching staff heeds the critique, the quarterback‑receiver pairing could see a shift in target distribution, potentially unlocking new offensive schemes that leverage Faison’s speed and route precision.
The conversation underscores a broader theme in college sports: the need to balance hype with hard‑earned evidence when shaping a team’s narrative.