Toby Kinney has stepped into the role of head coach for the Vail Mountain School boys soccer program, succeeding Kevin Ives, who guided the team to the 2022 state championship. Kinney arrives with a clear vision that goes beyond wins, aiming to embed a distinct team identity rooted in courage, intelligence and joy while maintaining rigorous standards.
A Philosophy Built on Opportunity and Cost
At the heart of Kinney’s approach is a focus on understanding both opportunity and the cost of each decision on the field. He believes that success is measured not only by scores but by how players grow through the challenges presented to them, fostering an environment where high expectations coexist with genuine enjoyment of the game.
The program’s recent history adds context to Kinney’s mission. In the 2024 season the team posted a 1‑12‑2 record, falling in the second round of the state tournament twice. That stretch highlighted the need for renewal, especially after the graduation of top scorers Winston Pillsbury and Calvin Schaffler, whose departure removes roughly 15 points and four goals from the offense.
Despite those losses, the roster retains key contributors. Colm Kinney, Toby’s son, returns with six goals and 12 points, while Alec Uribe adds four goals and 12 points. Seniors Gabe Fletcher and Kaleb Gibbs bring leadership and experience, providing a stable core as the team integrates younger talent.
New Faces and Returning Strength
The squad also welcomes back Caspian Covarrubias‑Walker from injury and adds newcomers such as mogul skier Luca Dispense and multi‑sport athlete George Reihe. Assistant coaches Jordan Kauk, Chris Robinson and John Linn will support Kinney in managing a roster of 26 athletes, ensuring that the developmental focus stays on the rise of underclassmen who are expected to make larger impacts after gaining valuable experience.
New athletic director Lisa Isom has praised Kinney’s demanding yet positive approach to strength and conditioning, noting that his standards are high but his demeanor remains encouraging. This blend of rigor and optimism is intended to push players beyond perceived limits while preserving the joy that initially drew them to the sport.
The early schedule presents tough tests, including a matchup against defending 2A state champion Crested Butte and a road trip to Salida, which fell in the state semifinals the previous year. The season will also feature contests against 3A and 4A opponents, culminating in a final game against Aspen on October 22. Kinney measures success by how well the team exceeds expectations and maintains a competitive edge in the postseason.