The Selection Process
The 2026 College Football Playoff conversation is already taking shape, and two prominent voices are shaping early forecasts.
Blake Toppmeyer and John Adams have teamed up to each compile a six‑team slate, ensuring that no player appears on both lists, which creates a broad snapshot of the anticipated field.
John Adams opens the discussion by tabbing Miami as his first selection, citing the Hurricanes’ strong returning core and aggressive recruiting.
Blake Toppmeyer counters with Notre Dame, arguing that the Fighting Irish’s schedule offers just enough flexibility to navigate a competitive landscape.
Texas earns a spot on Adams’ list despite concerns about a packed slate, as the Longhorns’ talent influx could tip the balance in their favor.
Toppmeyer adds Oregon to his lineup, expressing cautious optimism about the Ducks’ recent playoff pedigree while questioning consistency.
Georgia emerges as the safest bet from the SEC in Blake’s view, given the Bulldogs’ dominant defense and depth.
Ohio State joins the conversation on Blake’s board, mirroring Texas’ challenging path and raising expectations for a high‑octane offense.
John Adams includes Texas Tech, a move designed to keep Blake from claiming BYU, highlighting the strategic nuance behind each pick.
Indiana receives a nod from Blake, who sees the Hoosiers as a potential third straight playoff entrant thanks to steady improvement.
LSU’s inclusion on Adams’ list brings attention to quarterback Sam Leavitt’s health, a factor that could sway the Tigers’ fortunes.
Blake counters with Texas A&M, preferring the Aggies over Alabama and emphasizing their fortified defensive front.
USC shocks Blake with its selection by Adams, a surprising choice given the Trojans’ demanding schedule and the need for a turnaround.
Boise State rounds out Blake’s choices as the Group of Six representative, underscoring the importance of a non‑Power Five qualifier.
Together, the hosts stress that these early projections are fluid, subject to injury, recruitment cycles, and emerging storylines as the season unfolds.